The Highlights
- The government offered and leased 5,241 acres of public land in New Mexico for oil and gas development at below-market royalty rates.
- Industry interest varied widely, with bids ranging from roughly $126 to $154,001 per acre.
- Today’s average bid of $24,000 per acre is in line with the lease sales held under the previous 16.67% royalty rate, further evidence that royalty rates don’t determine auction results.
- Taxpayers are estimated to lose $23.4 million in royalty revenue from future production on these leases.
On November 18, the federal government offered and leased 5,241 acres of public land in New Mexico for oil and gas development at the recently reduced federal royalty rate of 12.5%. Over the life of the leases, this is expected to cost taxpayers an estimated $23.4 million in royalty revenue.
This sale adds to mounting projected losses. TCS estimates that taxpayers have already lost more than $1.7 billion in projected royalty revenue from leases sold since July 4, 2025, when the FY2025 reconciliation law reduced the federal onshore royalty rate to 12.5%, below what states and private landowners typically charge.
Results from Today’s Lease Sale:
The majority of today’s acreage was offered in the Permian Basin, the most prolific oil and gas producing region in the country, accounting for nearly 40% of all oil production and 15% of natural gas production in the United States. Industry interest in leasing in the region — on federal, state, or private land — has always been strong.
New Mexico sits at the center of federal oil and gas production. Over the last decade, it has consistently ranked as the largest producer of federal oil and natural gas. Oil production on public lands in the states has increased nearly fivefold over the last decade, while gas production has nearly doubled. Lease sales in New Mexico are among the most competitive in the country. In 2023, 2024, and 2025, nearly all acreage offered in the state received bids and the average bid per acre exceeded the average in every other state.
Today’s sale offered and leased 15 parcels of federal land, covering 5,241 acres, in New Mexico for private companies to lease and develop oil and gas, bringing the total amount of land leased in the state this year to a combined 78,000 acres. All 78,000 acres were leased at a royalty rate far below what is charged on state land.
Competitiveness in today’s sale varied widely, once again highlighting that industry interest is driven by development potential, not reduced royalty rates. Parcels sold for between $126 per acre (a parcel located outside of the Permian Basin) and $154,001 per acre (a parcel located in the Permian Basin). This variation on bids is common. The last federal lease sale in the state, held August 2026, had a similar range of $126 to $110,000 per acre. The sale before that, held May 2026, had an even wider range—from $11 to $357,000 per acre.
The amount private companies are willing to pay to lease federal land for oil and gas development depends heavily on the development potential of the specific parcels offered. Today’s sale provides a particularly stark example. Lea and Eddy Counties, located in the Permian Basin, are the largest producers of federal oil and gas in the country. Parcels located here received an average bid of $35,891 per acre in today’s sale. In contrast, the three parcels outside of the Permian Basin received a lower average bid of $1,177 per acre. Land leased in Kansas, Oklahoma, and Texas today received an even lower average bid of $207 per acre.
Below-Markey Royalty Rates Waste Millions in Taxpayer Revenue:
Unfortunately for taxpayers, the parcels leased today carry a 12.5% royalty rate, reducing the public’s share of revenue from any oil and gas produced from the leases.
Leasing decisions are driven by development potential and market conditions. Operators lease where there is strong development potential, and competitive market-based royalty rates do not deter industry interest or production decisions. Historic leasing date supports this point. Across the county, average bids at competitive auctions were actually higher under the 16.67% royalty rate that was in place in 2023 and 2024 ($978 and $2,149 per acre, respectively) than they had been during the preceding decade under the lower 12.5% rate ($379 per acre from 2013-2022).
The same pattern holds true in New Mexico. Today’s average bid of $24,000 per acre is in line with the $20,000 per acre average from the five federal lease sales held under the previous 16.67% royalty rate.
Rather, lower royalty rates only shortchange taxpayers by reducing future royalty revenue. As the largest producer of federal oil and gas, communities in New Mexico stand to gain the most state revenue from a modernized royalty rate. Between 2015-2024, taxpayers lost $13.9 billion from oil and gas development on federal lands in New Mexico under the 12.5% rate compared to an 18.75% rate, which is more in line with what is charged on state and private lands. New Mexico charges as high as 25% on certain state lands. Since roughly half of federal royalties are returned to producing states, communities in New Mexico lose out on nearly $7 billion. And with oil and gas production reaching record highs across the country, those losses are likely to continue growing.
The Bureau of Land Management estimates that the parcels leased today could ultimately produce 7 million barrels of oil and 23.2 billion cubic feet of natural gas over their productive lifetimes. Based on the White House Office of Management and Budget FY2026 price projections, which are used to estimate federal royalty revenue from onshore leases, that production would be worth roughly $561 million. At the 12.5% royalty rate taxpayers would receive about $70 million in royalty revenue, roughly $23.4 million less than what would have been received under a 16.67% rate.
State and Private Landowners Charge a Higher Royalty Than the Federal Government
The stagnant 12.5% minimum royalty rate charged on federal lands stands in stark contrast to the higher royalty rates top producing oil ang gas states charge on state land. Although BLM has the authority to charge higher than the minimum royalty rate, the agency has rarely done so. States such as New Mexico, Oklahoma, and Texas charge royalty rates of 18.75% to 25% for leases on state land, with higher rates often applied in high producing regions like the Permian Basin. Taxpayers are being shortchanged for resources produced on land that can be as close as a neighboring plot.
Congress has long considered increasing the minimum royalty rate, including during a major overhaul of the onshore oil and gas leasing system in 1987. At that time, officials at the Department of the Interior cited the use of the 12.5% rate on state and private lands as a reason for maintaining the same rate on federal lands. The subsequent adoption of higher rates for leases on states lands undermines that rational for continuing the 12.5% rate in federal leases. While Congress acknowledged this in 2022 with a rate increase to 16.67%, the increase was short-lived and repealed in 2025.
Lowering Financial Assurance Requirements Increases Taxpayer Risk
After production ends, oil and gas producers operating on federal land are required to plug their wells and reclaim surrounding sites. To help ensure that producers pay for cleanup, they must post a bond before drilling begins. If a company completes the required cleanup, the bond can be returned. If a company abandons its wells or goes bankrupt, the bond is forfeited and used to help cover reclamation costs.
BLM currently accepts two types of bond coverage: bonds for an operator’s wells on an individual lease carry a minimum of $150,000, while bonds covering all of an operator’s wells within a state carry a minimum of $500,000. This June, BLM proposed lowering those requirements to their decades-old minimums of $10,000 for an individual lease and $25,000 for all wells in a state. In 2023, these inadequate minimums left average bond coverage at just $3,873 per well, only 5% of the average cost of reclamation. If outdated bonding requirements return, the lease issued today and any future leases could add to those liabilities.
These proposed requirements stand in sharp contrast to recent updates implemented by the New Mexico Oil Conservation Commission for oil and gas operators on state land. In July 2026, New Mexico adopted new financial assurance requirements that raised the minimum single well bond amount from $25,000 plus $2 per foot to $150,0000, and the blanket bond from a $50,000 to $250,000 scale to $250,000. The new rule also requires single-well bonding for marginal and inactive wells and requires inflation adjustments to help ensure bond minimums do not once again become outdated. Local leaders in New Mexico acknowledged the high costs of reclaiming wells by modernizing their financial assurance and well-management framework—yet DOI has proposed to dramatically lower financial assurance requirements for wells on federal land, which may sit less than a mile from wells on nonfederal land and are no less expensive to reclaim, putting taxpayers at greater risk.
Modernized Leasing Terms Support Responsible Development, Generate Revenue, and Protect Taxpayers
To add insult to injury, BLM is planning to offer more than half a million acres of public land to private companies to drill for oil and natural gas between now and December 17, all with the same taxpayer liabilities that plagued today’s sale. Oil and gas developed on federal lands belongs to the American people, and leasing terms should ensure taxpayers receive a fair return from the development of these valuable resources. New Mexico’s strong bonding requirements and higher royalty rates don’t inhibit competition. So why are federal leases continuing to shortchange taxpayers?
- Public Domain-USGS