After months of failing to negotiate a bipartisan agreement on topline Pentagon spending, Senate Republican appropriators released text of the long-delayed Senate Defense Appropriations Act this week, providing $1.07 trillion in base Pentagon spending, which roughly matches the president’s request including a $234 billion increase over this year’s enacted discretionary Pentagon spending.
The proposal might look like an $80 billion cut compared to the $1.15 trillion Senate version of the National Defense Authorization Act. But the authorization bill includes funding for military construction and the Department of Energy’s nuclear weapons programs, which appropriators fund through separate appropriations bills. For the accounts this bill actually covers, the Senate proposal comes within $25 million of the Trump administration’s request, a negligible difference in the context of a trillion-dollar-plus budget.
Notably, the $1.07 trillion includes $69 billion moved over from the separate $350 billion the Pentagon requested through reconciliation, a pretty good sign that Senate appropriators at least don’t think another Pentagon spending splurge through reconciliation is likely to materialize. That reconciliation request included funding for several priorities that were more partisan or controversial than those in the base request, such as the unviable and prohibitively expensive Golden Dome program, and a good deal more F-35s than were included in last year’s budget. The new Senate bill includes $9.4 billion for Golden Dome, along with an additional $5.7 billion for the F-35 program, bringing total F-35 spending in the bill to roughly $14 billion.
The majority of the funds shifted from reconciliation—at least $42.4 billion—focus on munitions. The Iran War has raised legitimate concerns about U.S. munitions stockpiles, but throwing money at the problem is not a good solution. Replenishing stockpiles will take years, a reality that no amount of money will change. In the short term, the most important step lawmakers can take to address munitions shortfalls is to prevent their ongoing depletion by reining in the unauthorized war with Iran, which means reining in funding, not piling it on.
When replenishment does happen, it should also incorporate lessons from the war rather than pursuing a one-for-one approach. Roughly $32 billion, or three-quarters of the munitions spending brought into the bill from the reconciliation request would fund expensive missile systems such as Patriot and THAAD interceptors. While some replenishment there may be warranted, the war has demonstrated that these systems are not a cost-effective approach to defending U.S. positions during a protracted conflict, so rather than doubling down, new investments should focus on more affordable systems.
To its credit, the Senate proposal did have some good news for taxpayers: the $1.84 billion requested for the Trump-class battleship, a costly and ill-conceived ship, was axed—a remarkable rejection of a presidential priority for a partisan bill drafted by members of the president’s party.
The other bit of good news for taxpayers is that this bill is effectively dead on arrival. In the aftermath of a stinging defeat in the midterm elections, Republican appropriators may not even be planning to vote this bill out of committee, much less secure the bipartisan support it would need to become law.
So why release the bill at all, one might ask? The answer is two-fold. First, Senate appropriators like to have something to point to in negotiations with their House counterparts, and a bill with limited support is better than no bill at all. But second and perhaps more importantly, the explanatory statement accompanying the bill includes hundreds of individual program increases that appropriators anonymously shoved into the bill, some of which may benefit the campaign contributors of their sponsors. When lawmakers eventually negotiate a bipartisan spending agreement, many of those increases will find their way into the final bill.
Looking forward, lawmakers have until December 11, when temporary government funding expires, to either pass some or all 12 appropriations bills or pass another continuing resolution (CR) to cover what they haven’t completed. Failing that, the country will face another costly government shutdown. Hopefully lawmakers learned their lesson last year and can work across the aisle to pass at least a CR before Americans pay the price.
On the Pentagon spending front, another continuing resolution seems like the most likely outcome. But whether it’s this year or next, Democrats have made clear that they won’t support the kind of Pentagon increase espoused in the Senate’s Pentagon spending bill. So, the real question is, how much are they prepared to cut? For lawmakers seriously considering that question, we have about 518 billion places to start, which we detailed this summer in a joint cut list with the Project on Government Oversight: How to Cut Half a Trillion from the Pentagon Budget Request and Strengthen National Security.